Ghosal, Chaudhury, Kumar, Khilar, and Rout: Epidemiology, clinical profile, complications and treatment outcomes of chronic dacryocystitis in a tertiary care hospital in post lockdown era: An observational study


Introduction

Chronic dacryocystitis is a long standing infection of the lacrimal drainage system, resulting in blockage of the normal drainage system.1 Nasolacrimal duct obstruction (NLDO) is the predominant cause of dacryocystitis as obstruction and subsequent retention of tear and mucous leads to secondary infection.2 The cause of nasolacrimal duct obstruction is idiopathic in most of the cases.2 However, secondary obstruction may be caused due to trauma, chronic sinusitis, tumour, granulomatous diseases (Tuberculosis, Wegener’s Granulomatosis).3 Chronic dacryocystitis leads to continuous epiphora which is the most common presenting feature. Other symptoms may be mucoid, muco-purulent or purulent discharge, pain, swelling of lacrimal sac area, chronic conjunctivitis or keratitis, pre-septal cellulitis etc.

External Dacryocystorhinostomy (DCR) is the treatment of choice for most patients in idiopathic acquired NLDO. It is a surgical procedure in which an anastomotic pathway is created between the lacrimal sac and the nasal mucosa through a bony ostium.4 Dacryocystectomy (DCY/DCT) is done in old ages with comorbidities or in presence of any pathology in the nasal mucosa or bony structures.4 Secondary NLDO is managed according to the causative pathology.

Though chronic dacryocystits due to NLDO is idiopathic mostly, there are few social and demographic factors which influence its occurrence, as stated by previous few studies. Moreover, the effect of COVID-19 pandemic and the prolonged nationwide lockdown (2020) has influenced everyone’s lives in form of hospital visits, being less conscious of one’s symptoms and most importantly, setting priorities on the livelihood. Thus mild to moderate symptoms (epiphora, mucopurulent discharge, painless swelling) which are not disastrous to one’s life, often got overlooked and it lead to significant epidemiological and clinical changes in cases of chronic dacryocystits.5

Materials and Methods

An observational study was designed from July 2020 to December 2020 in Regional Institute of Ophthalmology, Cuttack, Odisha, India. All the patients presenting with chronic dacryocystits were evaluated thoroughly in various epidemiological parameters such as age, gender, residence, occupation, comorbidities. The history and clinical features were noted, e.g. duration, number of attacks of acute dacryocystitis, epiphora, discharge, pain, swelling, previous surgery/procedure etc. After proper evaluation and conservative treatment, those patients were subjected for surgery (External Dacryocystorhinostomy/ Conjunctivo-dacryocystorhinostomy / Dacryocystectomy) and the surgical outcomes were followed-up upto 3 more months, i.e. March 2021.

Inclusion criteria

  1. All cases diagnosed as chronic dacryocystitis.

  2. ROPLAS test positive.

  3. Lacrimal Passage Irrigation showing regurgitation from opposite/same puncta.

  4. Both soft and hard stop on probing.

  5. Acute on chronic presentation.

Exclusion criteria

  1. Patients not giving consent to the study.

  2. Patients lost to follow-up.

  3. Secondary dacryocystitis due to nasal or bony pathology which requires treatment for the causative disease (tumours, wegener’s, rhinosporidiosis, tuberculosis).

  4. Congenital dacryocystitis.

Results

A subtotal of 206 patients were diagnosed with chronic dacryocystitis. Among them, 187 patients fulfilled all the inclusion and exclusion criteria’s. 8 patients were lost to follow-up, 4 did not give consent for further study and 7 had significant nasal or systemic disease which required intervention from the respective departments.

It was found that, during the study period, total attendance in the outpatient department of RIO, Cuttack was 16829. So, the prevalence was around 1.224%.

Figure 1

Pie chart showing prevalenceof chronic dacryocystitis among the patients attending RIO, Cuttack during the study period

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage1.png

Among the 187 patients, 112 were female (59.9%) and 75 were male (40.1%). So, there is clear female preponderance.

Figure 2

Pie diagram showing gender distribution among the patients of chronicdacryocystitisin the study.

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage2.png

Chronic dacryocystitis was observed mostly in middle to old aged people with highest incidence in 51-60 years (30.5%). The percentage of cases in <20 years age group is 0.5%, however it is 1.6% in 21-30 years, 7.5% in 31-40 years, 24.6% in 41-50 years, 25.7% in 61-70 years and 9.6% in >70 years age group.

Figure 3

Bar diagram showing age distribution among the patients of chronic dacryocystitis/in study group

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage3.png

Chronic dacryocystitis is seen in right side in 74 cases (39.6%), left side in 79 cases (42.2%) and bilaterally in 34 cases (18.2%).

Figure 4

Pie diagram showing laterality of involvement among the patients of chronicdacryocystitisin the study

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage4.png

Most of the patients in the study group belonged to the rural population in Odisha 90.4% (169 patients), whereas 18 patients were from urban areas (9.6%).

Figure 5

Pie diagram showing residential status amongpatients chronic dacryocystitis in the study

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage5.png

To determine the socio-economic status, we used the modified B.G. Prasad scale (2020). The study showed that, most of the patients belonged to social class 4(31%), followed by class 3(27.8%), class 2(20.3%), class 5(11.2%) and lastly class 1(9.6%).

Figure 6

Pie diagram showing social class (modified B. G. Prasad scale 2020) among the patients with chronic dacryocystitis in the study.

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage6.png

Analysis regarding the occupation of all these patients showed that most number of patients are housewives (39.6%) followed by farmers (21.9%). Businessmen (13.9%) and labourers (12.3%) also contributed significantly.

Figure 7

Bar Diagram showing occupational factors among patients withchronic dacryocystitis in the study.

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage7.png

Regarding clinical features, 134 patients (71.6%) presented with epiphora which was the commonest symptom in the study group. Presence of mucopurulent discharge, pain, swelling in lacrimal sac area were present in 29.9%, 10.7%, 12.3% cases respectively. Other complications like conjunctivitis, keratitis, preseptal cellulitis, cutaneous fistula were seen in 6.4%, 8.4%, 7.5% and 5.9% cases respectively.

Figure 8

Bar diagram showing presenting clinical features among the patients with chronicdacryocystitis in the study.

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage8.png

Enquiry is also made regarding any co-morbid condition which may affect the disease and surgical outcomes. History and laboratory work-up showed 37 patients having type 2 diabetes mellitus, 51 having hypertension, 4 with coagulation profile derangement, 23 with moderate to severe anemia (Hb<10gm/dl), 6 with cardiac disease, 5 with chronic liver disease, 5 with chronic kidney disease. 2 patients had history of DCR surgery in the same side.

Figure 9

Bar diagram showing co-morbidities among the patients with chronicdacryocystitis in the study.

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/b88b3be9-54bc-4888-8b7a-b49d5ed0494dimage9.png

After proper evaluation, pre-operative preparations and patient consent, total of 158 patients were taken up for surgery. DCY was done in 14 patients due to nasal/systemic pathology, old age being unfit for DCR. Among other 144 patients, 3 had canalicular block, so Conjunctivo-DCR was done with Lester Jones tube for those cases. Rest 141 patients had undergone external DCR under local anesthesia. After follow-up for at least 3 months, 20 patients of external DCR had reported reversal of previous symptoms, that is failure of surgery. So, the success rate for this surgery is 85.8% as per 3 months follow-up duration. However, no patient undergoing DCY or conjunctivo-DCR had reported any symptom signifying failure of surgery.

Discussions

In our study, higher incidence of disease was found in Females that is 112 (59.9%). This higher incidence in female may be attributed to narrow lumen of bony lacrimal canal and higher vascular congestive factors. It is comparable to a study carried out by Pawar and Patil6, where incidence of Chronic dacryocystitis was seen in females in 56% of cases. Other comparable studies are Jacobs HG,7 R. Dalgleish et al8 (54%). Higher incidence of 61.6%, 67.86% and 84.6% were noted in Payal Katre et al,9 Surendra P W et al10 and Saxena R C et al11 respectively.

We also found that the disease prevalence was highest in the age group of 51-60 years that was 30.5% followed by 25.7% in the age group of 61-70 years which is similar to Surendra P W et al10 study. Jacobs HG7 in his study found maximum incidence in age group of 40-55 years. While Saxena RC et al,11 R Dalgleish et al8 and Sarda et al12 quoted a maximum age incidence in the 4th decade in their separate studies.Duke Elder S13stated that the disease preferentially affects adults over middle age being relatively rare in children and adolescents. The highest incidence quoted by him also was in the fourth decade of life.

In our study 42.2% had left sided obstruction, 39.6% had right side obstruction and 18.2% had bilateral obstruction. There is no significant laterality found. This is in accordance to the studies done by Reddy P S et al,14 Jacobs HG,7 Pandey R et al15Ramamani et al.16

The prevalence of Dacryocystitis is also very much related with socioeconomic status and its impact on living standard. and people belonging to class 4 & 3 were affected more, similar to Surendra P W et al10 and Acharlu et al17 in which they showed more prevalence in class 3 and 5. This can be attributed to poor hygienic conditions and low living standards. Presence of allergens such as household smoke, dust, pollen, agricultural pesticides may bethe causative factors, which has an important role in chronic sinus infections and chronic inflammation of the nasolacrimal duct. In our study, 90.4% were from rural population. The rural population of Odisha is 83.32%, so more predilection in rural community is anticipated.

The study showed that majority of the affected were housewives (39.6%) and farmers (21.9%), followed by small businessmen (13.9%) and wage labourers (12.9%) which showed that majority of the patients belonged to poor and low middle class families who lack in their cleanliness and hygiene. Outdoor exposure to irritant substances may also be an important factor in farmers and labourers. Chronic Dacryocystitis is less common among people of urban areas with middle class to rich class who can afford maximum hygienic measures. Surendra P W et al10 reported most cases among daily labourers followed by farmers.

In our study, epiphora was the commonest presenting symptom in 134 patients (71.6%) followed by the symptom of mucopurulent discharge in 29.9% and swelling near the medial canthus in 12.3% cases. It correlates well with studies by Hartikainen J et al,18 Reddy PS et al14 which showed most common presentation as epiphora in 76% and 80% cases respectively. Zilelioglu G et al19 reported the incidence of epiphora in 86% and discharge in 3% cases.

Complications like conjunctivitis, keratitis, preseptal cellulitis, cutaneous fistula were present in 6.4%, 8.4%, 7.5% and 5.9% cases respectively in our study, all of which are more as compared to previous studies. It may be related to the prolonged lockdown before the study period, for which rural patients could not attend any medical facility.

Hypertension (27.3%) was the commonest associates in the study group which is consistent with the Indian population (29.8%). 19.8% of our study group had type 2 Diabetes mellitus which is more than the double of Indian population (8.9%). Diabetes have definite role in delaying the normal healing process which attributes to the chronicity of the disease.

The success rate of external DCR was reported as 85.8% in this study. It is similar to the data shown by M. Alnawaiseh et al20 and Badhu B et al21 who showed success rate of 82.8% and 88.6% in their respective studies. Other literatures22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 showed wide range of success rate (80%-95%).

.

Conclusion

Chronic Dacryocystitis, though a common problem of lacrimal drainage system and most commonly presenting only with epiphora, is much less recognized disease, specially in rural population and in lower socio-economic community, thus patients may present late with one or more complications. Form our descriptive study design, it was seen that chronic Dacryocystitis was more common in females and in age group 51-60 years. It was more prevalent in rural Odisha, in lower socio-economic strata. Mostly affected persons were housewives, followed by farmers, small businessmen and labourers. If presented late in healthcare facilities, complications like conjunctivitis, keratitis, preseptal cellulitis, lacrimal abscess, mucocele, cutaneous fistula may occur which is the current scenario in post-lockdown era. Maintaining all precautions and guidelines for COVID-19, we should not delay treating these patients with surgical measures. The disease may not look immediate sight-threatening but it has long term complications either with life-long annoying epiphora or some serious complications like keratitis, orbital cellulitis, sinusitis, even meningitis, cavernous sinus thrombosis and brain abscess. The surgical success rate (85.8%) however is not affected much in spite of all these factors related to late presentation. This might decrease if long term follow-up period is adopted.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflicts of Interest

All contributing authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

1 

Zia Choudhury Post graduate Ophthalmology 22020138991

2 

B Bowling Kanskii Textbook of ophthalmology8th Edn.Saunders Ltd.2015715

3 

American Academy of Ophthalmology8th Edn.6970

4 

MR Levine RC Allen Manual of Oculoplastic surgery5th Edn.8392

5 

SK Basak Essential ophthalmology5th Edn.20164750

6 

M D Pawar S N Patil Kuglerand Ghedini A new approach to stent dacryocystorhinostomy in cases with blockage of the lacrimal drainage systemProceedings of the XXV International Congress of Ophthalmology1986Milan, Italy188292

7 

HB Jacobs Symptomatic epiphoraBr J Opthl1959437415910.1136/bjo.43.7.415

8 

R Dalgleish Idiopathic acquired lacrimal drainage obstructionBr J Ophtholmol1967517463810.1136/bjo.51.7.463

9 

P Katre Epidemiological study of dacryocystitis in rural population PanaceaJ Med Sci201771114

10 

SP Wadgaonkar PA Patil DB Nikumbh SS Rathod CM Sawat Epidemiology of chronic dacryocystitis with special reference to socioeconomic status: A rural hospital studyIndian J Clin Exp Ophthalmol20162151610.5958/2395-1451.2016.00009.3

11 

RC Saxena KC Garg Scope of Dacryocystorhinostomy. J India Ophthal Soc196917558

12 

RP Sarda OP Kulshrestha RN Mathur DacryocystorhinostomyBr J Ophthalmol19614521384310.1136/bjo.45.2.138

13 

DS Elders S Disease of lacrimal passages; system of ophthalmologyXIII part-IIMosby Publication1974675724

14 

PS Reddy BS Reddy Dacryocystitis; Aclinico-pathological studyJ Indian Med Assoc195514136

15 

R Pandey Dacryocystorhinostomy and the superior-inferior flap techniqueIndian J Ophthalmol196715947

16 

R Dalai R Rout S Mohapatra S Mohapatra A Study on Clinical Profile and Outcome of Chronic Dacryocystitis in Adults in a Tertiary Care Center, ParipexIndian J Res201889

17 

PB Acharlu S Vijayalekshmi State of the Art Study on Epidemiology of Chronic Dacryocystitis in Rural CommunityInt J Cur Res Rev 2020121010310.31782/ijcrr.2020.12103

18 

J Hartikainen OP Lehtonen KM Saari Bacteriology of lacrimal duct obstruction in adultsBr J Ophthalmol1997811374010.1136/bjo.81.1.37

19 

G Zilelioglu O Tekeli S H Ugurba Results of endoscopic endo- nasal non laser dacryocystorhinostomyDoc Ophthalmol200210515762

20 

M Alnawaiseh N Mihailovic AC Wieneke V Prokosch A Rosentreter RL Merté Long-Term Outcomes of External Dacryocystorhinostomy in the Age of Transcanalicular Microendoscopic TechniquesJ Ophthalmol201620161410.1155/2016/5918457

21 

B Badhu S Dulal S Kumar SKD Thakur A Sood H Das Epidemiology of Chronic Dacryocystitis and Success Rate of External Dacryocystorhinostomy in NepalOrbit2005242798210.1080/01676830490916073

22 

D Horix H G Struck Long term patency rate of the external dacryocystorhinostomy. A retrospective study in the years 1991-2000 at the University Eye Hospital in HalleOphthalmologe2004101326877

23 

J Huang J Malek D Chin K Snidvongs G Wilcsek K Tumuluri Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on Outcomes for Endoscopic Versus External DacryocystorhinostomyOrbit2014332819010.3109/01676830.2013.842253

24 

J. Mäntynen M. Yoshitsugu M. Rautiainen Results of Dacryocystorhinostomy in 96 PatientsActa Oto-Laryngologica1997117187910.3109/00016489709124118

25 

GA Shun-Shin G Thurairajan External dacryocystorhinostomy---an end of an era?Br J Ophthalmol1997819716710.1136/bjo.81.9.716

26 

JF Warren SR Seiff MC Kavanagh Long-Term Results of External DacryocystorhinostomyOphthalmic Surg, Lasers Imaging Retina20053664465010.3928/1542-8877-20051101-03

27 

R Saha P Kumar RP Maurya VP Singh MK Singh R Kumar Endoscopic V/s External Approach DCR: A comparative AnalysisIndian J Clin Exp Ophthalmol2015131374210.5958/2395-1451.2015.00004.9



jats-html.xsl

© This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 07-05-2021

Accepted : 26-05-2021

Available online : 24-07-2021


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijooo.2021.030


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 265

PDF Downloaded: 101



Wiki in hindi